Change Is To Be Expected, But Not Always Welcomed

John Marcille

The biggest threat to managed care as now practiced may be this new scheme, defined contribution. Even more than the Patients' Bill of Rights, this is a movement that could shake the industry. But as seen in our cover story, the term "defined contribution" covers a range of financing and delivery mechanisms.

In pure defined contribution, the employer hands the worker some pretax earnings and says, buy yourself some health care. That model isn't seen too often. In other models, the employer retains some control, but care often is not prepaid, as it is in an HMO.

We at Managed Care understand employers' desire to make workers feel the pain of health care premium inflation so that they will have an incentive to moderate their consumption, but we are highly skeptical of "solutions" that would drive healthy young workers into low-cost plans and herd sicker folk into other types of plans. For generations, employer-sponsored health coverage has minimized the variation in workers' out-of-pocket costs, and nobody ever warned today's older workers, who dutifully subsidized their elders' care in the past, that we would cancel the deal when they started to need care for more serious conditions.

You will hear people call these new plans "consumer-driven" and call the movement "consumerism." It is true that the new systems require the patient to make decisions, and there may be much good in that. But "consumerism" and "consumer-driven" imply that the impetus for these systems came from consumers. That's untrue. Consumers want choice of providers, and the Patients' Bill of Rights began as a consumer bill. But the defined contribution movement is being forced on workers by employers. And there are serious concerns about whether it will result in better health care — or worse. It certainly will be a challenge to HMOs.

Career Opportunities

HAP, a subsidiary of Henry Ford Health System, is a nonprofit health plan providing coverage to individuals, companies and organizations. This executive develops strategies to meet membership and revenue targets through products, pricing, market segmentation and advertising.  Aligns business among Business Development, Commercial Sales, Medicare and Public Sector Programs and Product Development. Seeks to enhance and be responsible for business development and expansion through the development of an effective product portfolio, strong interpersonal relationships and service excellence.

Apply via email to or online at

Subscribe to Our Newsletters

Monthly table of contents

Be notified as each issue of Managed Care is available online.

Biweekly newsletter

Recent topics have included:

PTCommunity news

New drug approvals, clinical trials, drug management. Three times per week.


Managed Care
By Peter Wehrwein
Managed Care
By Howard Wolinsky