Managed Care


U.S. Supreme Court To Hear Suit Against HMOs Over Incentives

MANAGED CARE November 1999. © MediMedia USA
News and Commentary

U.S. Supreme Court To Hear Suit Against HMOs Over Incentives

MANAGED CARE November 1999. ©1999 MediMedia USA

Can HMOs be sued for the practice of offering bonuses to physicians who help them keep the cost of care down? That's a question the U.S. Supreme Court has agreed to decide this term, in the first major case involving HMO liability to reach the high court.involving HMO liability to reach the high court.

An Illinois woman says her appendix rupture could have been avoided had her physician not delayed diagnostic tests for more than a week so they could be performed at a lower cost at a facility owned by her HMO.

The woman alleges that her physician stood to gain financially by limiting referrals, and that the health plan violated its duty to members by denying proper care. A lower court had dismissed her claim, but it was later upheld by the Seventh U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. That court ruled that incentives do not necessarily constitute a breach of responsibility, but added that when incentives lead a physician to withhold needed care, liability can arise.

Elsewhere, liability cases have moved forward. A federal appeals court ruled that a suit against Aetna U.S. Healthcare can proceed in Pennsylvania state courts, on grounds that HMOs are not immune from state malpractice suits. Similarly, the Illinois Supreme Court ruled patients may sue HMOs for physician negligence. (To read about the implications of the Illinois cases, see this month's "Ethics" column)


2014 Annual HEDIS® and Star Ratings Symposium Nashville, TN November 3–4, 2014
PCMH & Shared Savings ACO Leadership Summit Nashville, TN November 3–4, 2014
Medicare Risk Adjustment, Revenue Management, & Star Ratings Fort Lauderdale, FL November 12–14, 2014
World Orphan Drug Congress Europe 2014 Brussels, Belgium November 12–14, 2014
Healthcare Chief Medical Officer Forum Alexandria, VA November 13–14, 2014
Home Care Leadership Summit Atlanta, GA November 17–18, 2014
6th Semi-Annual Diagnostic Coverage and Reimbursement Conference Boston December 4–5, 2014
Customer Analytics & Engagement in Health Insurance Chicago December 4–5, 2014
Pharmaceutical and Biotech Clinical Quality Assurance Conference Alexandria, VA December 4–5, 2014
9th Semi-Annual Medical Device Coverage and Reimbursement Conference San Diego December 5, 2014
8th Annual Medical Device Clinical Trials Conference Chicago December 8–9, 2014
HealthIMPACT Southeast Tampa, FL January 23, 2015