MANAGED CARE July 2012. ©MediMedia USA
Tufts Offers Its Workers Short Commute to Care
Though ROI is hard to calculate, insurer says that its on-site clinics are changing employee behavior for the good
When Tufts Health Plan opened its Be Well Center for its own employees in February, it did so as a self-insured company, the kind that tends to rely more on clinics than those that aren’t self-insured. Tufts wasn’t doing a pilot test of a product to be sold. It has no plan to offer these clinics to employer sponsors or insured companies, says Lydia Greene, vice president for human resources and diversity.
In this case, Tufts is just one of many companies focusing more on wellness, as was noted in last year’s study of 588 companies by the National Business Group on Health and Towers Watson, which says that 23 percent offer wellness services and another 12 percent plan to begin offering them this year.
The Be Well Center, which is managed by Take Care Health Systems, a subsidiary of Walgreens, is available to 1,700 Tufts employees on the company’s Watertown, Mass., campus. Be Well complements the insurer’s Working Well Center, a fitness facility that offers classes in nutrition, exercise, yoga, acupuncture, and massage. The Working Well Center, also managed by Take Care, offers 35 classes a week and costs employees $28 a month. The Be Well Center is staffed by a nurse practitioner, a medical assistant, and a wellness coach, and there’s a local PCP who oversees the operation.
Improving productivity and overall workforce satisfaction are goals. The Tufts wellness program began about seven years ago as part of a broad company culture change. “For each of the last three years the annual increase in health benefit costs has been under 3 percent,” says Greene. Yet she concedes that “determining ROI can be challenging.”
The Center for Studying Health System Change has addressed workplace clinics, saying, “Employers need to be realistic about return on investment, and that measurement poses challenges.” The study, “Workplace Clinics: A Sign of Growing Employer Interest in Wellness,” says that while some experts argue that clinics can achieve a positive ROI in the first year, most don’t expect to break even for at least two years, possibly longer (http://snurl.com/243tyxq). It doesn’t help that there are no industry standards for measurement. “Two types of ROI are typically estimated: ‘hard ROI,’ which measures savings in direct medical costs only, and ‘soft ROI,’ which also includes productivity gains from such factors as reduced absenteeism,” says the study.
Greene says, “What we do know is wellness programs can improve employee morale, and that’s always a welcome ROI.”
For instance, Tufts aims for that most daunting of wellness goals: long-term, sustainable weight loss. That’s where the Be Well and Working Well centers work hand in hand. “We have a full-time wellness coach in the Be Well Center,” says Greene. “She helps identify and overcome whatever obstacles to wellness might be present in a person’s life. She can refer you to our on-site nutritionist or she can give you a free pass to the gym for a couple of months. Close to 50 percent of the individuals who choose coaching over a three- to six-month period are focused on weight loss.”
For years the gym had about 125 members. In the last four years, that’s grown to more than 500, nearly a third of the campus population.
“I would have been pretty skeptical about this four or five years ago,” says Greene. “But my experience here has made a believer out of me. When you change the culture and make it comfortable for an overweight person to be in a gym or participate in a cycling class, you make it accessible and acceptable as a workplace practice.”