Purpose: Preterm birth (PTB), defined as birth at a gestational age (GA) of less than 37 weeks, is associated with increased hospital costs. Lower GA at birth is negatively correlated with the presence of neonatal comorbidities, further increasing costs. This study evaluated incremental costs associated with comorbidities of PTB following spontaneous labor at 24–36 weeks.
Design: Birth records from January 2001 to December 2010 at the Medical University of South Carolina were screened to identify infants born at GA 23–37 weeks after uncomplicated singleton pregnancies and surviving to discharge.
Methodology: Comorbidities of interest and incremental costs were analyzed with a partial least squares (PLS) regression model adjusted for comorbidities and GA. Incremental comorbidity-associated costs, as well as total costs, were estimated for infants of GA 24–36 weeks.
Results: A total of 4,292 delivery visit records were analyzed. Use of the PLS regression model eliminated issues of multicollinearity and allowed derivation of stable cost estimates. Incremental costs of comorbidities at a mean GA of 34 weeks ranged from $4,529 to $23,121, and exceeded $9,000 in 6 cases. Incremental costs ranged from a high of $41,161 for a GA 24-week infant with a comorbidity of retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery (ROP4) to $3,683 for a GA 36-week infant with a comorbidity of convulsions. Incremental comorbidity costs are additive, so the costs for infants with multiple comorbidities could easily exceed the high of $41,161 seen with ROP4.
Conclusions: The PLS regression model allowed derivation of stable cost estimates from multivariate and highly collinear data and can be used in future cost analyses. Using this data set, predicted costs of all comorbidities, as well as total costs, negatively correlated with GA at birth.
An increasing worldwide incidence of preterm birth (earlier than gestational age [GA] 37 weeks) has been reported in recent years (IOM 2007, Blencowe 2012). In 2010, an estimated 14.9 million babies were born preterm, representing 11.1% of live births worldwide (Blencowe 2012). Preterm birth rates are generally highest in low income regions; however, the United States has one of the highest incidences, which peaked at 12.8% in 2006 before decreasing to 11.4% in 2013 (IOM 2007, Blencowe 2012, Hamilton 2014, Martin 2011). In 2010, 35.2% of all US infant deaths were deemed to be related to prematurity (Matthews 2013).
Preterm birth is associated with greater infant morbidity and increased health care costs, including higher delivery visit costs due to longer hospital stays and a greater need for intensive care due to medical care related to morbidities of prematurity (IOM 2007, McLaurin 2009). In a US national study conducted in 2001, 8% of infants were judged as preterm, accounting for 47% of the total cost of infant hospitalizations and 27% of the cost for all pediatric admissions, or $5.8 billion in all (Russell 2007). Overall, most premature infants born in the United States each year are either moderately premature (31–33 weeks gestation) or later preterm (34–36weeks gestation) (Martin 2011). Together, these 2 groups account for more than 70% of all preterm births. A retrospective, US-based study published in 2009 demonstrated infants born 33–36 weeks GA had substantially longer mean birth-hospitalization stays than term infants (8.8 vs 2.2 days) and incurred mean hospitalization costs of $26,054—more than 12-fold greater than those reported for term infants ($2,061) (McLaurin 2009).
Although the moderately and late-preterm birth populations make up a greater proportion of costs for the entire population, the per patient costs and rates of morbidities associated with prematurity are much greater in the lower GAs. Studies have demonstrated that the rates of comorbidities associated with prematurity increase in infants with decreasing GA (Berard 2012, Stoll 2010). Respiratory distress syndrome (RDS), for example, has been reported in 82% of infants born at GA 25 weeks compared with 0.6% of infants born at GA 38 weeks (Gilbert 2003). Therefore, the cost burden of preterm birth is often increased by further treatment for associated comorbidities and negatively correlates with GA at birth (Matthews 2013, McLaurin 2009). However, few studies explore how costs vary with the diagnosis of comorbidities of prematurity and GA.
High and potentially increasing rates of preterm birth are an important issue due to the associated social and health care cost burdens of prematurity (IOM 2007). Complete and valid estimates of costs and cost drivers associated with prematurity at differing weeks of gestation are needed to inform allocation of health care resources and support the development and reimbursement of therapies that may help to prevent preterm labor and preterm birth, identify best practices and/or quality measures, and further the implementation of cost-effective treatments.
This study was designed to evaluate the incremental costs associated with premature birth and neonatal comorbidities of prematurity at a GA of between 24 and 36 weeks. In addition, the study explored whether stable cost estimates could be derived for use in future economic evaluations or costing studies.
A retrospective review of 14,276 maternal and infant records from January 2001 to December 2010 at the Medical University of South Carolina (MUSC) identified infants born at GA 23 to 37 weeks to mothers who had been admitted in spontaneous preterm labor with intact membranes following uncomplicated singleton pregnancies. MUSC is a regional tertiary referral hospital in the southern United States with a perinatal database (Perinatal Information System) containing detailed delivery information and neonatal data from birth to discharge, including diagnosis codes for babies born at each GA week. Data on total hospital charges, as calculated with a specific algorithm for each insurer/payer, were available for all infants. Prior studies of the cost during the neonatal period, showed that neonatal costs tended to be higher for preterm infants who survive compared with those who die (Johnson 2013). Also, very premature infants who die are likely to die in the first 2 weeks of life and are less likely to be diagnosed with a comorbidity. Thus, our analysis included all infants who survived to discharge, irrespective of the presence of comorbidities of interest. Thirteen recognized comorbidities associated with prematurity were identified (Stoll 2010, Gilbert 2003, Finer 2006, Johnson 2013, Okike 2014, Simonsen 2014, Strauss 2010). In addition to RDS, they included bronchopulmonary dysplasia (BPD), sepsis, meningitis, necrotizing enterocolitis (NEC), intraventricular hemorrhage I & II and III & IV (IVH I/II & IVH III/IV), periventricular leukomalacia (PVL), anemia requiring transfusion, apnea, retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery (ROP4), convulsions, and brain injury (PVL/choroid plexus cyst, porencephalic cyst, and/or acquired hydrocephalus).
Costs for preterm birth with no comorbidities, together with incremental costs for the presence of any of 13 comorbidities, were estimated at a mean GA of 34.3 weeks using a partial least squares (PLS) regression model. Data were adjusted for comorbidities and GA, log transformed, and inserted into the PLS model to calculate the effect of 27 variables (presence or absence of any of 13 comorbidities plus week of GA at birth) on incremental health care costs. Tenfold cross-validation of the full model using an independent data set not used during the training stage of the PLS model optimized the predictive accuracy of the PLS model (Picard 1984). Cost outliers were retained in the model and bootstrapping was used to test model stability.
Costs for preterm birth with no comorbidities, together with comorbidity-associated costs at any GA (24–36 weeks), were subsequently calculated from the mean value according to the following equation:
Predicted cost = (incremental comorbidity cost estimate) − (comorbidity adjusted for GA) × (gestational age difference [from the mean value of 34.3 weeks]).
The study sample included 4,292 delivery visit hospital records for infants born at GA 23–37 weeks. Demographic distributions are presented in Table 1. Comorbidities of interest identified most commonly across all infant records were RDS (19.8%), apnea (12.5%), anemia requiring transfusion (7.9%), and BPD (5.8%) (Table 1). One of the main problems when applying multivariate regression and discriminant analyses is the collinearity among the variables used in the models. Such collinearity problems can lead to serious stability problems when the methods are applied. Transformation of our infant cost data and implementation of the PLS regression analysis model eliminated issues with collinearity, leading to stable incremental cost estimates (cross-validated R2, Q2 = 0.69) that correlated with actual costs observed in the database (Figure 1). To estimate the precision of our sample statistics (medians, variances, percentiles) we used bootstrapping statistics (drawing randomly with replacement). Further analysis demonstrated that the model was stable under bootstrapping, and that the accuracy of prediction was preserved when outlier cost data were retained (Figure 1).
|Total number of infants||4,292||100.0|
|Brain injury (PVL/CPV)||44||1.0|
|a Other=American Indian, Asian, other.
b Comorbidities do not add up to 100% due to the presence of subjects with either no or multiple comorbidities.
BPD=bronchopulmonary dysplasia; IVH=intraventricular hemorrhage; NEC=necrotizing enterocolitis; PVL=periventricular leukomalacia; PVL/CPV=periventricular leukomalacia/choroid plexus cyst, porencephalic cyst, and/or acquired hydrocephalus; RDS=respiratory distress syndrome; ROP4=retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.
Predicted vs observed costs (US$) during cross-validation of the partial least squares means analysis with outliers retained
Cross-validation of the partial least squares (PLS) model using an independent data set not used during the training stage of the PLS model indicated strong performance (R2=0.69) of the model during prediction. The majority of predicted values correlated well with known observed costs in this data set (red line shows perfect correlation), with only a few outliers where costs were underestimated.
The estimated cost of preterm birth at a mean GA of 34 weeks was $3,431. Incremental cost estimates for comorbidities in infants born at GA 34 weeks exceeded the estimated cost of births without complications in all cases, and ranged from $4,529 for convulsions to $23,121 for ROP4. Costs in excess of $9,000 were associated with the presence of any of the following comorbidities at 34 weeks GA: BPD, $11,652; sepsis, $9,040; NEC, $10,371; IVH (III/IV), $9,447; anemia requiring transfusion, $9,590; and ROP4, $23,121 (Table 2).
Estimated incremental cost of comorbidities adjusted for GA and further comorbidities
|Variable||Incremental cost estimate at Week 34.3 (US$)||Cost adjustment for each increase in weekly GA at birth (US$)|
|Birth without complications (intercept)||3,431||−884|
|BPD=bronchopulmonary dysplasia; GA=gestational age; IVH=intraventricular hemorrhage; NEC=necrotizing enterocolitis; PVL=periventricular leukomalacia; PVL/CPV=periventricular leukomalacia/choroid plexus cyst, porencephalic cyst, and/or acquired hydrocephalus; RDS=respiratory distress syndrome; ROP4=retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.|
Adjusting the predicted costs for differing GA at birth demonstrated a negative correlation between GA and total associated costs for all comorbidities, as well as for a birth without complications (Table 2). Adjustments from the mean GA at birth (34 weeks) for comorbidities ranged from $423 (convulsions) to $1,804 (ROP4) per weekly decrease in GA, whereas the cost of preterm birth with no comorbidities increased by $884 for every reduction in GA by week (Table 2). The cost of preterm birth without comorbidities was estimated at $1,663 at GA 36 weeks, increasing more than sevenfold to $12,271 at GA 24 weeks. The cost of comorbidities also rose incrementally over the GA range; the presence of BPD, for example, entailed costs of $9,356 at GA 36 weeks compared with $23,132 at GA 24 weeks. Incremental costs for all comorbidities of interest at GA 24, 30, and 36 weeks are shown in Figure 2, while full breakdowns of costs for comorbidities at GA 24 to 36 weeks are listed in Table 3.
Comorbidities of prematurity: estimated incremental costs at GA 24, 30, and 36 weeks
BPD=bronchopulmonary dysplasia; GA=gestational age; IVH=intraventricular hemorrhage; NEC=necrotizing enterocolitis; PVL=periventricular leukomalacia; PVL/CPV=periventricular leukomalacia/choroid plexus cyst, porencephalic cyst, and/or acquired hydrocephalus; RDS=respiratory distress syndrome; ROP4=retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.
Adjusted cost (US$) estimates of comorbidities by GA (weeks) at birth
|GA at birth||RDS||BPD||Sepsis||Meningitis||NEC||IVH I/II||IVH III/IV||PVL||Anemia||Apnea||PVL/CPV||ROP4||Convulsions|
|BPD=bronchopulmonary dysplasia; GA=gestational age; IVH=intraventricular hemorrhage; NEC=necrotizing enterocolitis; PVL=periventricular leukomalacia, PVL/CPV=periventricular leukomalacia/choroid plexus cyst, porencephalic cyst, and/or acquired hydrocephalus; RDS=respiratory distress syndrome; ROP4=retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.|
Total costs of preterm birth for infants with comorbidities (preterm birth plus incremental comorbidity-associated costs) at GA 36 weeks ranged from $5,346 with convulsions to $21,176 with ROP4. In comparison, total costs at GA 24 weeks ranged from $21,030 with convulsions to $53,432 with ROP4. Costs by GA for birth with and without selected comorbidities are shown in Figure 3.
Total estimated costs of preterm birth with, and without, selected comorbidities of prematurity
BPD=bronchopulmonary dysplasia; ROP4=retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.
There is a shortage of reliable data on the cost of comorbidities associated with prematurity by GA. Johnson (2013) is the only other study to explore the costs of multiple comorbidities of prematurity. Their study differed from ours by focusing on very low birth weight (VLBW) infants (<1500 g) and considered only 4 comorbidities of prematurity (brain injury, which comprised IVH, PVL, and acquired hydrocephalus; NEC stages 2 & 3; BPD; and late-onset sepsis). They reported marginal costs, controlling for GA, birth weight and socioeconomic status, thus not allowing the reader to explore how costs would vary with increasing or decreasing GA. Our results allow for the exploration of how costs will vary for different GAs in addition to the impact of individual and overlapping comorbidities of prematurity. Thus, our results allow the user to calculate the costs of prematurity based on the distribution of premature births by GA seen within an institution in addition to adjusting these costs by the distribution and incremental costs of 13 of the most common comorbidities associated with prematurity. This would allow for the tailoring of cost calculations based on incremental costs for specific GA and comorbidities of interest rather than the use of diagnostic-related groups (based on birth weight classifications) or Clinical Classifications Software categories (used by Healthcare Utilization Project–HCUP), which cluster patient diagnoses and procedures into grouped codes. This is an important step toward enabling payers to anticipate the costs of individual cases and allow for better management of benefits based on the needs of individual infants.
Initially an ordinary least squares (OLS) regression model was explored as a means of analyzing the comorbidity incremental costs, with GAs grouped together. This approach to the analyses generated results that were unstable and not representative of the continuous nature of the data. There were also issues with multicollinearity (e.g., 2 or more predictor variables in the regression model being highly correlated) between comorbidities and their interactions with GA, resulting in unstable coefficient estimates (even negative estimates). The PLS regression model that was subsequently adopted for this analysis allowed straightforward insertion of multicollinear variables within a single model, which generated stable and accurate estimations of the variables of interest (cost by GA and costs for individual comorbidities) and their relationships (Chin 2003). In this analysis, 10-fold cross-validation allowed the generation of a PLS model with optimized predictive accuracy (Picard 1984). We ran the model with outlier cost data excluded and included, and ended up retaining outlying cost data in the model, as there was a lack of effect on predictive accuracy or stability, and it had the added benefit of providing real-world representative predictions.
The data generated by this model demonstrate that PLS can overcome some of the inherent weaknesses associated with OLS models and can be used to provide stable predictions with good cross-validated performance even when data contain observational errors and multiple, highly collinear, explanatory variables—a scenario likely to occur when observational data are used for predictive analysis (Simonsen 2014). In this study, PLS modeling demonstrated that GA at birth was inversely associated with incremental health care costs. Costs associated with comorbidities of prematurity, as well as costs resulting directly from birth, were highest in infants born at lower GA. The greatest total estimated costs were associated with births at the lowest GA complicated by severe and costly comorbidities.
Limitations of this study include the single-site origin of the data used to populate the PLS model. MUSC is a tertiary referral center and the data obtained may not be representative of births nationwide. Also, a high proportion of the populations were either uninsured (indigent, 16.5%) or enrolled in Medicaid (57.3%), which may have resulted in cost estimates lower than those that may be seen at sites with higher rates of private insurance. Therefore, validation of these results using data from multiple sites could enhance the accuracy of predictions that might be generalized across US or global settings. As our analysis excluded multiple pregnancies, babies born to mothers with pregnancy complications, and infants with congenital abnormalities, the cost estimates provided here are also likely to be conservative.
GA at birth was inversely associated with delivery visit hospital costs. Additionally, total predicted costs were increased further by the association of comorbidities with preterm birth. The results of this study have broad implications and uses. These results could be used to guide development of quality improvement measures for treatment of preterm infants. Quality improvement measures in the neonatal intensive care unit have primarily focused on babies born in the lowest gestational age ranges because they have the highest risk of death or morbidity and costs, but they make up roughly 5% of the premature infants born in the US each year (Martin 2011). Cost data from this study could be used to support development of quality improvement measures for treating preterm infants across the entire GA range, as our study demonstrates that costs and morbidities vary across the entire GA range.
Before quality measures can be maximized to treat babies born prematurely, they should first focus on prevention of preterm birth, as this is the preferred way to reduce mortality and morbidity associated with prematurity. The results of this study could also be used to inform economic models that assess cost-effectiveness of the treatment of preterm labor and prevention of preterm birth and could be used to guide reimbursement policy.
The costs of premature birth are substantial. The results derived from the PLS model detail how these costs can vary depending on an infant’s GA at birth and whether the infant develops comorbidities associated with prematurity. These results can be used in future economic analyses that explore the economic impact of therapies to prevent preterm birth or for treatment of preterm infants.
Berard A, Le TM, De Vera MA. Study of the costs and morbidities of late-preterm birth. Arch Dis Child Fetal Neonatal Ed. 2012;97(5):F329–F334.
Blencowe H, Cousens S, Oestergaard MZ, et al. National, regional, and worldwide estimates of preterm birth rates in the year 2010 with time trends since 1990 for selected countries: a systematic analysis and implications. Lancet. 2012;379(9832):2162–2172.
Chin WW, Marcolin BL, Newsted PR. A partial least squares latent variable modeling approach for measuring interaction effects: results from a Monte Carlo simulation study and an electronic-mail emotion/adoption study. Inform Syst Res. 2003;14(2):189–217.
Finer NN, Higgins R, Kattwinkel J, Martin RJ. Summary proceedings from the apnea-of-prematurity group. Pediatrics. 2006;117(3 Pt 2):S47–S51.
Gilbert WM, Nesbitt TS, Danielsen B. The cost of prematurity: quantification by gestational age and birth weight. Obstet Gynecol. 2003;102(3):488–492.
Hamilton BE, Martin JA, Osterman MJK, Curtin SC. Births: preliminary data for 2013. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2014;63(2).
IOM (Institute of Medicine Committee on Understanding Premature Birth and Assuring Healthy Outcomes). Preterm birth: causes, consequences, and prevention. In: Behrman RE, Butler AS, eds. The National Academies Collection: Reports funded by National Institutes of Health. Washington, DC: National Academies Press. 2007:1–20.
Johnson TJ, Patel AL, Jegier BJ, et al. Cost of morbidities in very low birth weight infants. J Pediatr. 2013;162(2):243–249.
Martin JA, Hamilton BE, Ventura SJ. Births: final data for 2009. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2011;60(1):1–70.
Matthews TJ, MacDorman MF. Infant mortality statistics from the 2010 period linked birth/infant death data set. Natl Vital Stat Rep. 2013;62(8):1–26.
McLaurin KK, Hall CB, Jackson EA, et al. Persistence of morbidity and cost differences between late-preterm and term infants during the first year of life. Pediatrics. 2009;123(2):653–659.
Okike IO, Johnson AP, Henderson KL, et al. Incidence, etiology, and outcome of bacterial meningitis in infants aged <90 days in the United Kingdom and Republic of Ireland: prospective, enhanced, national population-based surveillance. Clin Infect Dis. 2014;59(10):e150–e157.
Picard RR, Cook RD. Cross-validation of regression models. J Am Stat Assoc. 1984;79(387):575–583.
Russell RB, Green NS, Steiner CA, et al. Cost of hospitalization for preterm and low birth weight infants in the United States. Pediatrics. 2007;120(1):e1–e9.
Simonsen KA, Anderson-Berry AL, Delair SF, Davies HD. Early-onset neonatal sepsis. Clin Microbiol Rev. 2014;27(1):21–47.
Stoll BJ, Hansen NI, Bell EF, et al. Neonatal outcomes of extremely preterm infants from the NICHD Neonatal Research Network. Pediatrics. 2010;126(3):443–456.
Strauss RG. Anaemia of prematurity: pathophysiology and treatment. Blood Rev. 2010;24(6):221–225.
- Quality improvement measures in the neonatal intensive care unit have focused on babies born in the lowest gestational age (GA) ranges because they have the highest risk of death or morbidity and costs, but they make up roughly 5% of the premature infants born in the US each year.
- This study involved a retrospective review of 14,276 maternal and infant records from January 2001 to December 2010 at the Medical University of South Carolina of infants born at a GA of 24 to 36 weeks.
- The estimated cost of preterm birth at a mean GA of 34 weeks was $3,431. Incremental cost estimates for comorbidities in infants born at 34 weeks GA exceeded the estimated cost of births without complications and ranged from $4,529 for convulsions to $23,121 for retinopathy of prematurity requiring surgery.
- The cost of comorbidities rose incrementally as gestational age decreased. For example, the presence of meningitis entailed costs of $4,698 at 36 weeks, $9,354 at 30 weeks, and $14,010 at 24 weeks.
- The data generated by this model show that the partial least squares model can overcome some of the inherent weaknesses associated with the ordinary least square model and can be used to provide stable predictions.
- This study was conducted at a single tertiary referral care center, so the data may not be representative of births nationwide.
Funding Source: This study was funded by GlaxoSmithKline (GHO-11-5081).
Disclosures. Black is employed by GlaxoSmithKline and is a GlaxoSmithKline shareholder; work performed on this publication was done while she was employed by GlaxoSmithKline. Lee and Parks are employees and shareholders. Hulsey and Ebeling are employees of the Medical University of South Carolina and were contracted and paid by GlaxoSmithKline to conduct the study. No one was compensated for participation as an author. All authors met the International Committee for Medical Journal Editors criteria for authorship, were fully involved in manuscript development, and assume responsibility for the direction and content.
Acknowledgement: Assistance in the preparation of the manuscript was provided by Matthew Thomas of Caudex and funded by GlaxoSmithKline.
Paul Lendner ist ein praktizierender Experte im Bereich Gesundheit, Medizin und Fitness. Er schreibt bereits seit über 5 Jahren für das Managed Care Mag. Mit seinen Artikeln, die einen einzigartigen Expertenstatus nachweisen, liefert er unseren Lesern nicht nur Mehrwert, sondern auch Hilfestellung bei ihren Problemen.